using issue status (what does "patch, needs work" mean?)

Hi,

When you use this website to create an issue, it will by default have status="active". You can choose a status from a combo-box with different values like "fixed" or "won't fix" and so on. It is not always clear which status applies in which situation.
There is a page at Drupal.org that describes the status values and how they are designed to be used: http://drupal.org/node/156119 but that page is not so very clear either. Especially the status values with "patch" in their name are hard to understand.

I believe that status "patch, needs work" means that somebody raised an issue and then somebody else created a patch, attached that patch as a file, and is still not very proud of himself and says that the patch needs work, maybe because the patch is an emergency workaround while the preferred solution requires a different approach, or what have you. If he would have felt more secure he might have set the status to "pach, ready for commit" if he does not have access-rights for the source control system.

So I think a new issue should have status "active" which means that the status needs to be reviewed and assigned, and that status "patch" means that a patch has been created and is available for download.

Now if all this seems confusing, then I propose that I simply remove the three "patch" statusses.
How do you feel about that?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
rpy's picture

Patch

Ah, well then i misunderstood. I inerpreted this as 'we need to work on a patch'. The issues assigned to the developer to work on now have this status. It's ok to remove the 'patch' statuses and replace them with something like 'under development' or something.